All Blogged Up: A Moof’s Tale -

All Blogged Up: A Moof’s Tale

Ooooopsie! 0_o

February 2nd, 2009

Indeed!

Several of my fellow bloggers and I have decided to crosspost our ideas concerning the woman with six children who just delivered octuplets. I’ve tried to not read their posts because I didn’t want to be influenced, but I did end up getting sneak peeks at Dr. Bate’s and Dr. Rob’s posts. I agree with both of them … although I think I’m approaching the issues from a different perspective.

Please visit their blogs and consider leaving comments … do you agree? Disagree? Why? Let’s have an interesting, civil exchange of ideas concerning this rather controversial event.


The crossposting group:

Dr. Bates from
Suture for a Living

Dr. Rob from
Musings of a Distractible Mind

Robin from
Survive the Journey

Carrie from
NeoNurseChick

Also see:

Fat Doctor
Fat Doctor

Barbara Duck
The Medical Quack

Dr. Cris Cuthbertson
Scalpel’s Edge

Note: More links could appear as people crosspost! Keep an eye on us!


Duggar family I’ve never made a secret of the fact that I’m a very conservative person. We’ve had some really good discussions here in the past about abortion, suicide where Alzheimers is concerned, the ownership of guns … etc. … those of you who know me well won’t be surprised that I would begin by tackling this very ticklish issue before moving on to the others: fetal reduction.

I understand that a reduction might have made the pregnancy “safer” for the mother and the remaining infant(s), but seriously, in what manner was safety even part of the equation from the outset? Things were already so badly out of control once the ova were implanted that there really was no safe path to follow from that point. How many should have been killed? 2? 4? More? And which ones? Would the woman have simply been able to say: “Okies now, leave me one of each, and get rid of the rest”?

When I think of that sort of thing, I can’t help but picture an old farmer drowning the latest batch of kittens because he doesn’t want any more cats in the barn. People today would be outraged if they knew someone was drowning little kittens and puppies … but where’s the outrage when someone terminates the life of the tiniest and most helpless of our own species? They’re genetically unique individuals, who, if allowed to live, could grow into someone’s husband, or wife, or best friend … or even into someone who might have been able to heal some of the world’s problems. I feel that once a human child is conceived due to the actions of other people, he shouldn’t be the one to pay the ultimate price.

My own babies are now adults, and have become my precious friends. I don’t know what I would do without them. I was told to abort two of them, and wouldn’t. I look at them today and I remember what other people wanted me to do, and I can’t even begin to describe what I feel. Just because unborn babies haven’t shown you who they are yet, doesn’t mean that they’re not people.

And in summary: I don’t believe that we can arrogate the right to chose life or death for any other individual – at any stage of life. I know that a lot of you will disagree with me, some of you vehemently, and that’s fine. I don’t want to do your thinking for you, and I will respect your opinion. Please, if you’re going to comment, respect mine.

Funny thing – how a person who is simply trying to express what they feel so often seems to sound as if s/he is preaching when you don’t agree with what is being said, isn’t it?

Now … for the rest of the story …

In the last few days, bits and pieces of information about this woman and her living conditions have leaked out …

She’s unmarried, and lives with her parents in what we’ve been told is a 3 bedroom house. She has six other babies at home, the oldest of which is 7, and the youngest are a pair of twins who were born about two years ago. According to her mother, she’s been obsessed about having babies since she was a teenager, and conceived each of her children through in vitro fertilization. The grandmother told reporters that she was not supportive of what her daughter was doing, and that she had warned her daughter that when she got home from the hospital, “[She was] going to be gone.” 1

Now, seems likely to me that the young woman involved must have been a least a french fry short of a “happy meal” to not only do this sort of thing once, but to continue until she hit a double jackpot at the one-armed-bandit of the obstetrics world! A person can love children and babies to the point of foolishness, but even then – deliberately going on to have more in vitro babies after already having six, seems a bit over the top to me.

We don’t know much about her personally, and if the mother follows through with her decision and leaves, this young woman could be coming home to 14 kids to raise by her lonesome. Everyone who knows her says that she’s a good mother, and that, at least, is a relief, but I honestly don’t see how one person can give 14 children everything they need to be fully nurtured. I just hope for her sake (and her children’s) that she’s able to find a lot of helping hands … because in my mind’s eye, I can just about see the child protection people looking for excuses to “trim back the herd”. I don’t think their lives are going to be all that peachy and rosy … however I do wish them all the absolute best now that the deed has been done. It’s not the children’s fault.

The only individual I’m really perturbed with in this entire drama is the obstetrician who actually gave this woman fertility treatments! I’m assuming that her physician knows her well enough, if s/he’s going to agree to do this, that s/he’s aware that she’s been through successful implantations on 5 previous occasions. This was not a childless couple who were yearning for a baby of their own! This is a single mother … with 6 children at home, all under the age of 10! If s/he is the same one who did the other implantations, then s/he must also have had some idea that the woman would be likely to refuse a reduction if a ridiculous number of the ova actually took.

If the young woman wasn’t responsible enough to know when to quit, I don’t understand why the authority figure didn’t just refuse to be a partner in this insanity! Why wasn’t the obstetrician able to tell her:

No! Absolutely not! I just can’t do that. It would be dangerous, you could even die and leave 6 children orphaned! That would just be crazy. In fact, here’s a referral to a very nice doctor I know that I’m sure you’ll like very much …

Someone in that room should have had the common sense to put on the brakes! It wouldn’t have stopped her from trying other doctors, but each well meant refusal would at least have given her enough time and information to realize that what she wanted to do wasn’t particularly wise.

And finally, I’m FrancoAmerican (of the Canadian persuasion), and I am not personally against having large families. My French Canadian ancestors all had (or tried to have) big families. The child mortality rate was so high that you had to have at least two or three if you wanted one to live into adulthood. The families lived off the land, and the older children helped with chores and taking care of the younger children. Short of some sort of disaster, no one was hungry. Although it wasn’t really that long ago, it was still a different world than the one we live in now. Now families of that size are very rare, and incomprehensibly expensive to maintain. Enabling this single woman to have so many children – and more than half of them in one swoop, is unconscionably reckless. The physician who caused this to actually happen is doing well to stay out of the public eye, I believe, but s/he really should have to do a bit of explaining to the powers that be.


Sean Hannity with Ainsley Earhardt … interesting points which I han’t heard anyplace else …





1) Grandma: Octuplets mom obsessed with having kids


I reserve the right to delete any “over the top” comments, or comments with foul language and name calling. Personal attacks won’t be tolerated either. Feel free to express your own opinion, but please do so in a civil and respectful manner.

A New Post On Emanon’s Journey

August 31st, 2007

emanonheader.jpg

It’s been over a year since I’ve added a chapter to the Emanon’s Journey blog. It’s been a very difficult story for me to relate, up until now. In my daily life, the events which happened to “Emanon” are very far behind me, out of mind, and a world apart from my current reality. Writing about those days means reliving them – tearing myself out of where I am now, and dropping myself into a place that is sometimes painful beyond telling.

Putting myself into the right frame of mind has to be possible for me at the time, or I simply can’t write about it all. Hence – the long pause between chapters.

The chapter that comes after this one will make a transition from the earlier Georgia/”running and hiding” days, to when I met Doug, my husband. It should be a considerably easier chapter to write, and should not take me nearly as long to complete.

Those of you who haven’t read anything over on Emanon’s Journey yet, please don’t begin with this newest chapter. Try to begin at the beginning, which explains what the blog is all about, or at least begin with the “story” itself: “Such a Rainy Night in Georgia – Part 1.” That will give you more of an idea of what the blog is all about. Jumping into this latest post cold and unprepared … will just make it hard for you to understand what’s going on.

Years ago, I began to write an autobiography, knowing that if I could set things down the way they all happened – the abuse, the kidnapping, etc., that I would make a fortune if I could get the completed telling into the right hands. In less than a week, I abandoned the project. It was too painful, too difficult to relive. The immensely abbreviated version on the Emanon blog is difficult enough in the telling, although decades have passed since my first effort, and the events seem almost unreal – like someone else’s memories – when I think of them. Writing about them in detail, however, is another story, and unfolding those details as would be necessary in a book – is impossible for me.

And so – here I am, stretching my boundaries. Much of this is stuff that my closest friends don’t have the details of. How much easier it is to share the most painful, devastating details which a person’s memories harbor when doing so through the written word – especially when launching that word onto a large, nameless, faceless sea … than it is to sit in front of one quiet,attentive listener. There can be an amazing amount of anonymity and privacy in such a public medium.

Emanon’s Journey, Index
The new post is entitled: “A Nightmare of a Different Color

Contacts!

May 19th, 2007

If you haven’t heard from me, and you’re part of the medical blogosphere – it could be that I can’t put my hands on your email address! (Carrie, for one!!!) Please drop me a note if you want to know more about the forum. :o)

Another One Bites the Dust

May 19th, 2007

In the course of all of the upset over our dear Dr. Flea and our irrepressible Fat Doctor (YEAH!), I got an email from Cathy with more sad news. Dr. Dork, our poet blogger from Australia, has set his blog to private.

Four days – three blogging colleagues.

I researched the links which were left for me in the last post (thank you Mama Mia!) … and as I did, the sick feeling in the pit of my stomach kept rising. There’s an atmosphere of fear across the medical blogosphere.

In my meanderings yesterday, here are a few things I ran across. This really deserve some serious thought:

Found on Dr. Rob’s wonderful blog:

[...] I was called into the office of one of our attendings because the parent of a child was angry at me. I had made an off-hand comment on the elevator about a certain medication being worthless. We were just talking shop and doing our usual resident strutting. Apparently, this parent had felt that the drug that fell under my derision had done wonders for their child. They were so upset about this that they took down my name and told the attending of my waywardness. I thought this was ridiculous. If I had said that I don’t like Ford Escorts, would I have been pulled aside and chided because the child was brought to the hospital in a Ford Escort? I was voicing an opinion. It is certainly the parent’s right to disagree and even get angry, but I have equal right to hold and express my opinion.

I think some people feel it is their job to get offended. They look for ways to feel pain from innocent statements and then blame the person who made the statement for callousness. There is nothing wrong with talking about our lives, and even our frustrations with other people. We need to be sensitive in how we do it, but so does everyone. I would not talk about my neighbor any more harshly or openly than I do a patient. It is just plain courtesy.

[...]

My partners know I blog. My staff knows I blog. My wife and my Mom know I blog. If my patients ask, I give them the URL of my blog. I am me on my blog – faults and all. Some people out there seem to think that medical professionals aren’t just normal people. Thanks to the “professionally offended,” we are losing voices of real people doing hard jobs.

This is ironic, given the popularity of the new book: How Doctors Think. People want an author to tell them how doctors think, but God forbid that the doctors themselves should say how they think!

From over at BabyMedic:

I have never written about a patient or a call in a manner that I thought would enable direct identification of that person. All of the written names are pseudonyms, locations are changed (if they are mentioned at all), and I have done my best to be ambiguous, if not facetious, about demographic type details. I am familiar with the HIPAA regulations and I have taken great efforts to make sure my entries here are in accordance with them. It is my strong belief that the details I have written here cannot be used to determine the identity of any of my patients, through either direct or indirect means. These are the guidelines that I have written my entries by, and reading through the archives, I have not strayed.

From PDXEMT over at Drug-Induced Hallucinations:

While I greatly enjoy blogging, certain events recently have led me to believe that even though I am following HIPAA standards and protecting patient privacy, this may not protect my job.

And a “Twitter” from Vijay:

Remind me where it says ‘Land of the Free & Home of the Brave.” Declaration of Independence or the Constitution or Grimm’s fairy tales!

I’ve been telling my son about what’s happened, and he had an idea. He’s going to install a Forum for us, which will have open areas for anyone to write in, but will also have closed areas that no outsiders can access – not even the search engine spiders, and will only be accessible by the direct invitation of someone in that part of the forum. I’ll post a link to it as soon as it’s ready. Honest and open talk will be possible in there. The “closed rooms” will truly be bug free. It will be up to the people in each private segment to allow/disallow individuals who inquire about joining. We need a safe place to regroup, pull together, and fight back.

Blogdom Medical Hospital … (complete with doctors’ lounges, nurses’ stations, patient rooms, a public cafeteria served by a real life chef, and lots more) … coming soon to a location near you!

Vanishing Bloggers:

  1. One Injustice after Another
  2. Since When … ?
  3. Another One Bites the Dust
  4. Contacts!

Since When … ?

May 17th, 2007

You know, I can’t help but wonder what “they” think they can do to our Dr. Flea.

1. He always said what he thought …
2. I’ve never seen him be “arbitrary.” He always had a reason for what he believed.
3. He based his beliefs on what he felt was best for his patients
4. He was always careful to not stomp on anyone else’s rights.
5. He blogged anonymously, for heaven’s sake! Anonymously!!!
6. He never named his patients … or posted anything we could identify them through.

When I stop to think of all of that, I can’t help but feel a little scared. If they can make Flea take down his blog, or make him feel as if he has to take down his blog, then I don’t think that any of us are safe.

I’m not anonymous … anyone who really wants to can find my name, place of birth, and the name of the town I live in, all buried in my blog. I’ve been as outspoken as our dear Flea, where my own areas of interest are concerned … …

Wait! What’s what you’re saying? You’re saying: “But MOOF! You’re NOT A DOCTOR!”

Ohhh yeah! That’s right! I’m not a doctor. I shouldn’t have to worry then, right? Give that some thought, people, because that’s even scarier

If you and I can say what we want – unmolested – certain of our right to express ourselves, certain that what we say is not going to be used against us as long as we don’t harass or abuse other people, then why would belonging to medicine change the rules? Aren’t doctors allowed to have their say? How about anonymously???

If it doesn’t bother you, disturb you deeply, even frighten you, that in the US today, our physicians can’t even blog anonymously without facing some sort of legal retribution or inquiry, then you just don’t understand the implications of what’s happening.

This is not justice, friends. Since when does an entire class of people have to live in fear of expressing themselves openly in this country???

I’m going to research, and begin to keep a list of all of the physician bloggers (and nurses?) who’ve been forced to either quit blogging, or go private. I would like to know just how extensive this problem is. I would like to know how extensive OUR problem is – because when an entire class of people are oppressed, with their basic rights abridged, it’s our collective problem!

I’m going to become Detective Moof … (Hey! I like the sound of that! :o) … and I’ll report back with what I find. It may be time to start exposing those who would fatten themselves by feeding on people who spend their lives in service to others. Yes, mistakes happen, and sometimes – those mistakes can be tragic. Wherever there are human beings, there will be mistakes. I once had one doc tell me that he was convinced that my three other docs were “trying to do away with” me … imagine what a mean spirited person could have done with that! Wow! I’d be debt free, if I didn’t have a conscience … and some lawyer someplace would probably have a new boat.

Anyway, leave me comments on anyone you know who isn’t blogging anymore, or has gone private, and who is part of the medical profession. Let’s see what we discover …




For information about the Blogdom Memorial Hospital forum, please email me at Moof@blogsplot.net


Member

  • Perspective
  • Confidentiality
  • Disclosure
  • Reliability
  • Courtesy

medbloggercode.com





I won a Golden Llama Award!


Ask Dr. Rob: How to Choose a Pediatrician Poster!

Colorful wall poster of Dr. Rob's flowchart! Choose from a large 20.9" x 31.9" poster, or a nice glossy 11" X 17".

Click to view detail

Visit the Shop!



  • * Blogsplot Blogs *

  • *- Grand Rounds -*

  • .: Common Sense :.

  • .: FrancoAmerican :.

  • .: General Interest :.

  • .: Health & Allied :.

  • .: Medical Musings :.

  • .: Medical RSS :.

  • .: Spiritual Realm :.

  • .: Train Wrecks! :.

  • .: Word Press :.

  • Technomatics

  • ~ Asperger Syndrome ~

  • ~ On the Web ~


  • All original material, including text, photographs, artwork, © Doris Ballard 2005 through 2008