Breathe Dad! Breathe!
He was 84. His hair was starting to thin, but he still had more than many men half his age. Up until the age of 82, he had ridden his motorcycle to work every day. If there was anything he loved more than a good joke, a good meal, or an ice cold beer – it had to be spending time with his grandkids.
To me, he was immortal. At the time, the only way I would ever think of his age was to brag about him to myself: Look at him! 84! He still climbs up onto the roof at my brother’s house to make repairs, and does more in a day than I do in a week! It never occurred to me that he would ever not be there. My father would always be there.
In the summer of 1987, I drove up to Lewiston with a friend who was interested in buying my father’s motorcycle. My dad had taken a spill a few years before, he had executed a very tight u-turn at the top of a hill, and when he’d put his foot down because he’d lost momentum while making such a tight turn, his foot had ended up on the lower side of the hill, and the weight of the bike made him lose his balance. He attributed the fall to his age (I attributed it to the hill,) and he decided that his motorcycle days were over.
We’d made a date to meet him at his garage. Like my dad “ it seemed that the garage had always been there. He’d built it by hand about a decade before I was born. It still stands today, on the shores of the mighty Androscoggin River. We pulled into the yard of the garage, and I spotted his car. Everything was strangely quiet – no one else was around. The door to the garage was still closed, nothing stirred. It took me a moment to notice that my father was still in his car, with his head resting against the steering wheel, unmoving. I could feel a squeezing building up in my chest as I nearly flew the short distance to his car. I opened his door with my heart in my throat – and he looked up, smiled at me, and got out of the car, looking as if nothing at all had been wrong.
“Dad! You scared me! Are you okay?”
He smiled wryly and replied that he’d just been a bit dizzy, and had decided to rest for a few minutes. He cocked his head, peering at me over the top his glasses, and with the same crooked smile, he added: “The old man isn’t going to live forever, you know!”
I felt a physical jolt, as if I’d been punched. Just then, my friend came over to us, and began to ask my father about the motorcycle. With his words still ringing in my ears, I pretended that something in the distance caught my eye and I walked away, leaving them talking about the bike. I was grateful for the opportunity to wander off until I could gain control over the suffocating ache in my throat, and the tears which insisted on filling my eyes, in spite of my every effort to maintain my composure.
Three months later, the days were growing shorter, the nights were becoming quite cool. We were headed into another dreary, cold Maine autumn.
For once, I didn’t feel the fall dreariness dragging me down into the inevitable winter doldrums. I was light hearted, and joyful! It was October 1st, and my parents had just moved down from Lewiston to be near my brothers and I. With no forethought, we’d all managed to end up within a few minutes of each other in this tiny southern Maine town; it was good to finally have the family together again!
We’d spent the day helping them move into their little apartment, and once home for the evening, I was planning the remainder of my week. Dad had already made his meal requests: spaghetti and beef stew – soon please!
“My pleasure Dad!”
My pleasant reverie was interrupted by my dear friend Joanie, as she burst through the door without knocking. Her face was pale, and she looked terrible! I came up out of my chair and rushed over to her – I was certain that something terrible had happened.
All she could do was gasp: “He died!”
I held her while she cried – long, agonized sobs, wracking her body. How ironic! My best friend lost her father on the day that I got mine back. I drove Joanie and her mother to Central Maine Medical in Portland, and so began one of the worst two weeks of our lives.
The next morning, I went to my folks’ place, and told my Dad about my friend’s father. We had intended to introduce them. They were both mechanics, and we felt certain that they would develop a friendship. Sadly, it was not meant to be. My dad, my dear dad … that morning, he mourned the friend he would never get to meet.
Over the next week, we attended Joanie’s father’s funeral. I spent every free moment trying to get my parents settled in. With an undercurrent of guilt for Joanie’s sake, I exchanged silly stories with my dad, and felt a warm wash of love flow over me each time I saw him laugh or enjoy something I’d brought for him. I knew I’d never get tired of seeing him happy and laughing … it was so good to have him nearby! I planned all of the things we would together: I would share my favorite spots in the woods, where all of the wild berries and nuts grew. He and I had spent a lot of time doing that sort of thing when I was young.
The evening of the 8th day after my parents arrived, I got a call from my brother …
“Dad’s in the hospital.” I began to panic, and he hastened to add “Don’t worry, we just came from there, and he’s OK. He was asking for his glasses when we left so that he could read something. It’s late, so I wouldn’t go tonight.”
He explained that my father had fallen forward out of his chair, and landed on the floor, apparently unconscious. My mother had the presence mind to call an ambulance. It would be two more days before her Alzheimer’s would suddenly become so pronounced that we all realized that she had something terribly wrong with her. But on that day, she’d still had enough on the ball to do the logical thing.
The next morning, before I could organize myself to get out the door and rush over to see my dad, my brother called again …
“Dad took a turn for the worse during the night. I think you’d better get up to the hospital.”
And he had. He was no longer conscious. Sometime during the night, he’d had a massive stroke which left him in a coma, and unable to breathe on his own. I had missed seeing him while he was still conscious … missed hearing his voice for one last time … missed his smile … missed being able to tell him how much I loved him … to hang on … not leave us … please Dad … don’t leave!
I stayed by his bedside almost constantly, only going home to make sure my husband was feeding the kids, and that everything was OK there. Most of that day, I stood by my father, talked to him, caressed his hands, his face … kissed his forehead. I willed him to stay … but he didn’t respond – he couldn’t respond.
Day number 10 dawned, and the dread I was feeling was suffocating me – making it impossible to breathe. I wanted to climb into the bed beside my father, force him to get up, and take his place. I knew it wouldn’t help – it wouldn’t bring him back. Nothing I could do would ever bring him back.
We’d been told the night before that his EEG was horribly abnormal – he would never regain consciousness or breathe on his own again. The only reason he was alive was the respirator. We were told that we had a decision to make.
My brothers made the decision – the respirator would be removed, but if he tried to breathe on his own, we would then do everything we could to keep him with us. A very perceptive nurse realized that I was not comfortable with the decision, and she offered to withdraw the heart medication they’d started giving him on his first night there. She expected that nature would take its course then, and that no one would have to do anything as immediate and decisive as “pull the plug.”
My brothers agreed. The medications were withdrawn; over the next few hours, his heart got stronger, and his blood pressure went down to normal. He was tough – he’d always been tough. When it became apparent that removing his medication was not going to cause things to happen on their own, my brothers again made the decision to remove the respirator.
Everything inside of me rebelled – my Dad! We couldn’t do that to my Dad! The nurse quietly came in, and after giving me a look of deep sympathy, turned off the machine. My youngest brother was on his left … I was on his right, we were each holding one of his hands. Joanie had my mother in her arms at the foot of the bed, and my oldest brother was looking on from a short distance.
I cried silently as I waited for a miracle … which never came. My youngest brother, with his voice cracking, whispered hoarsely, “Breathe Dad! Breathe!” Tears were streaming down his cheeks. It seemed like an eternity before the line on the monitor went flat … two eternities. Memories flashed through my mind like a slide show … picking blueberries in the woods with him as a youngster … going up with him in his friend’s little Cessna on Sunday mornings after church … our first really long, honest, adult talk one day when he was dropping me off at nursing school … him holding me, not too many years before, and telling me how proud of me he was … and now, now he was gone. Irrevocably, irretrievably gone.
I looked up in confusion as I heard my mother reply “No, eh? Not really?” when Joanie told her that her husband was “gone.” In the less than 5 minutes between the nurse coming in and turning off the machine, and my father’s passing away, she had already forgotten what was happening. Our father died … and we realized then that we were also losing our Mom. By the time of the funeral, only a few days later, she no longer recognized one of her closest friends.
This October 10th will mark the 19th anniversary of my father’s death. I’ve never stopped mourning him. If he were still alive, he would have turned 103 this last April 13th.
Little girls of any age should never need to say goodbye to their Daddies.







May 14th, 2006 at 8:58 pm
That was such a sad and touching story. That must have been hard for you to write… I know the pain of losing a father.
You are sooo right. No one should have to say goodbye to their daddies. I am so glad that you got to spend more years with your daddy than I did.
May 14th, 2006 at 9:48 pm
What is it about Mother’s Day that makes me miss my Daddy so?
I think it is the way that he took such good care of my mom when he was here.
I’m so sorry for your loss to dear Moof.
May 15th, 2006 at 12:41 am
Sarah Honey … thank you, my dear heart. It was hard to write – and it wasn’t. Both. It just sort of gushed out of me, so writing it was easy enough … reliving it – wasn’t.
Honey, I know you should have had your Dad for a whole lot longer. I can’t imagine what you’ve been through … *comfort*
Pk … I don’t know, but I know what you mean. It’s the same with me. In my mind, my folks were inseparable – I really can’t think of one without the other. But although it’s Mother’s Day, it was my Dad who was on my heart. Sometimes they both get in there at the same time … and that can be especially painful. I miss them an awful lot. You’ve been through a lot more in that department than I have, my dear Pk … I’m sending you a hug across the miles.
May 15th, 2006 at 6:38 am
Moof,
Your story is both painful and touching. I have not felt the pain of losing a parent yet. I guess it brings one another step closer to facing mortality.
Your Dad sounds like he was quite the spirited gentleman! I can’t imagine riding a motorcycle at 82 years old.
The hairs on my arm stood up when you said your Mom had Alzheimer’s and that she forgot your Dad died right after. My Dad was diagnosed at 62 and he is 65 now…it is hard to watch him changing. He is so forgetful, impatient, so different than the man I’ve always known.
Thank you for sharing this beautiful story.
May 15th, 2006 at 6:41 am
Great post Moof.
May 15th, 2006 at 10:12 am
God Bless ya Moofie.
May 15th, 2006 at 12:01 pm
Pattie … yes, my Dad was real hot ticket. Great sense of humor, and tough and tender at the same time.
About your Dad … I’m so sorry. *comfort* I don’t want to go into details in this blog comment, but I have a lot I can say about what we went through with my Mom. She died 9 years ago this past May 7. The trauma of moving and my father’s death caused her Alzheimers to suddenly worsen … it was a nightmare. I’ve developed a few insights on dealing with a parent with Alzheimers as it progresses. I’ll be glad to share some ideas with you, if you’d like.
Dr. Scan Man … my friend! Thank you very much. Dr. IBear asked if I was going to submit something to Grand Rounds this week, and although I wanted to do something humorous, I guess it wasn’t meant to be … this is what came out instead.
Hey Fug! Thank you my dear. The sentiment and the blessing is appreciated!
May 15th, 2006 at 2:06 pm
I would very much so…perhaps on the 28th? ;)
May 15th, 2006 at 2:39 pm
Pattie! You’re on! :o)
By the way … I can’t *wait* until the 28th. Have you gotten all of the forwarded emails regarding time and place and so on?
May 15th, 2006 at 10:06 pm
I’m sorry for the loss and your pain.
I’m glad you have the wonderful memories.
May 16th, 2006 at 9:44 pm
Thank you TJ! I do, ineed, have some wonderful memories!
May 17th, 2006 at 12:34 pm
Sometimes, when I see an elderly person in a bed in the hospital, I stop and think, that was somebody’s little girl or boy once. It is hard to imagine a 90 year old on her mother’s knee, but certainly it was the case. It gives me some perspective.
The funny thing about losing a loved one is that you never really truly get over it. When I was young I thought the pain must go away sometime. It doesn’t. You just learn how to manage it — kind of like arthritis. I know people that I have lost, and I miss them every day. Never stops. That’s life I guess. On the bright side, it does mean that we really, truly, do love and cherish that person. Even when it hurts, there is something divine about loving another person.
May 17th, 2006 at 10:14 pm
Dr. Hebert, thank you. That was beautiful.
The imagery of seeing an elderly person as a infant is one I’ve also entertained. I try to imagine what they are really like, underneath the accumulated years.
It’s very true that you never get over losing someone you love. There’s a huge empty void that just never goes away, and that nothing else can fill. Again, like arthritis, sometimes you manage it … sometimes it manages you.
“Even when it hurts, there is something divine about loving another person.”
That was real poetry. Thank you again.
May 17th, 2006 at 11:15 pm
Okay, I’m crying now . . .I just can’t imagine losing my dad (either one). Moof, he isn’t really gone, not really . . .
May 18th, 2006 at 7:06 am
Thank you for visiting, Difficult Patient! Both of my Dads are gone now. We lost my father in law 1 year ago in April. He was as precious to me as my own Dad … and had been my “ally and partner in crime” for many years. It doesn’t matter how old you get, you never seem to outgrow the need for the love and presence of a parent.
Thank you for the kind words. Don’t be a stranger.
May 18th, 2006 at 8:03 am
Moof, my deepest sympathy on your loss. Clearly the pain is no less at 19 years and that speaks stongly to what a special man your Dad was.
Mama Mia
May 18th, 2006 at 8:14 am
Welcome to my blog, Mama Mia. Yes, he was a great guy … even though he’d be 103 now, it would still be too soon to lose him. Thank you for leaving a comment. Please visit me again.
May 18th, 2006 at 8:33 pm
Your story reminded me of a book I read…it was so touching. I often think about the day when I will experience losing a parent, and I think no matter what your age the loss is still so difficult. Thanks for writing your story.
May 18th, 2006 at 9:39 pm
Stephanie, thank you for visiting me and leaving a comment, and for your kindness.
You’re right – no matter what age you are, the loss is still so difficult. Well said. Love them so very much while you have them … study the way they move, the timbre of their voices … the little “looks” that set them apart from others. Those are the things you’ll get to keep of them.
Don’t be a stranger.